Key takeaways
- The A320 whistle does not come from the engine: Circular openings under the wings act like a blown-across bottle on approach. Newer or retrofitted aircraft carry small vortex generators in front of them and are much quieter.
- The bark on the ground is hydraulics: The A320 family’s Power Transfer Unit kicks in mainly when only one engine is running and sounds like a briefly barking dog.
- Low bypass ratio means loud and rough: The MD-80, with its rear-mounted JT8D-200 engines, sounds more like thunder than like a rushing noise on takeoff.
- Turboprops give themselves away with a rhythmic hum: The number of blades and the rotational speed of the propellers determine the pitch, and the soundscape is completely different from jets.
- Sound gives the hint, the eye decides: Hearing is a good early warning system but not a reliable type identification. Confirm with your eyes, binoculars or tracking data.
Contents
- 1.Identifying by sound: the short answer
- 2.The A320 whistle: a bottle tone under the wing
- 3.The bark at the gate: the Power Transfer Unit
- 4.The buzzsaw at takeoff: buzzsaw noise
- 5.The MD-80 thunder: low bypass ratio
- 6.Turboprops: hum instead of rush
- 7.Why sound can deceive
- 8.How to train your hearing
- 9.What to watch out for
- 10.Conclusion
You are at the spot, the camera is still in your bag, and from the direction of the approach comes a high, almost melodic howl. Experienced spotters often say “A320” before the aircraft even emerges from the haze. If you can identify aircraft types by sound, you have a real head start at the fence: you know earlier what is coming and have your camera up in time. This guide explains where the typical sounds come from – from the A320 family’s whistle through the hydraulic bark at the gate to the MD-80’s thunder and the turboprops’ hum – and where the limits of identifying by ear lie.
Heard, seen, posted
With Planetrack you record every sighting with photo, aircraft type, registration, airline and spot and collect it in your hangar. Planetrack is launching soon – join the waitlist and get early access.
Identifying by sound: the short answer
An aircraft sound is made up of a few sources: the fan at the front of the engine, the exhaust jet at the back, the propellers on turboprops and the airflow around the airframe – that is, landing gear, flaps, slats and openings in the outer skin. Depending on the phase of flight, a different source dominates. On takeoff at high power, you mainly hear the engine and the jet. On approach the engines run almost at idle, so airframe noise comes to the fore – and that is exactly where the most famous type sound of all shows up, the whistle of the A320 family.
That is why a sound is a hint, not an identification. It narrows the choices, and you have to confirm with your eyes, binoculars or tracking. How to assign types visually with confidence is shown in the guide Identifying aircraft types for beginners.
The A320 whistle: a bottle tone under the wing
The high, rising and falling howl that many residents and spotters associate with the Airbus A320 family does not come from the engines. Its source is circular openings on the underside of the wings that are part of the fuel tank pressure relief. When air flows over these openings on approach, the air in the cavity behind them starts to vibrate – the same effect as blowing across an empty bottle. Because the engines deliver little thrust on final approach, this tone stands out clearly then.
The classic models A319, A320 and A321 are affected – that is, the types you see most often at German airports anyway. The solution is surprisingly small: a vortex generator in front of each opening swirls the flow so that a clean tone can no longer form. Airbus has delivered aircraft of the family with these parts since February 2014, and older aircraft can be retrofitted. The noise reduction on approach is given as up to 4 decibels. Lufthansa has also put A320s with vortex generators into service.
For you as a spotter, that means:
- A whistle heard strongly suggests an older, non-retrofitted aircraft of the A320ceo family.
- No whistle does not rule out an A320. An A320neo or A321neo is newer than the modification, and many ceo fleets are retrofitted.
- How to tell ceo and neo apart visually – by engine size, sharklets and other details – is explained in the article A320neo or ceo?.
Looking is worth it
With a good telephoto lens, you can make out the small vortex generators in front of the openings on the underside of the wing even in photos of landing aircraft. Take a targeted look at your approach pictures sometime – you will then see which aircraft are still likely to whistle and which are not.
The bark at the gate: the Power Transfer Unit
The second distinctive Airbus sound you hear not in the air but on the ground: a short, rhythmic bark that often shows up during engine start or after landing on the way to the parking position. Behind it is the A320 family’s Power Transfer Unit (PTU). It mechanically links two hydraulic systems so that one can supply pressure to the other without any hydraulic fluid being exchanged between them.
The PTU kicks in when a significant pressure difference arises between the systems. That typically happens when only one engine is running – when starting the first engine, during shutdown or when a crew taxis to the gate on one engine after landing. The unit’s rapid spooling up and down produces the barking sound. It is often better audible in the cabin than outside, but at observation decks close to the apron it reaches you too.
So if it barks on the apron, an A320 family jet is very likely nearby. It is of course not a reliable type feature in the sense of A319 versus A321 – for that you need the fuselage length and emergency exits, as described in the guide Telling the A318, A319, A320 and A321 apart.
The buzzsaw at takeoff: buzzsaw noise
When a jet with a large fan engine stands at the runway threshold and pushes the power up, you often hear a buzzing, sawing sound from the front or diagonally from the side. Spotters and engineers call it buzzsaw. It arises when the tips of the fan blades rotate faster than the speed of sound at takeoff power. Shock waves form at each blade tip, and because the blades are never exactly identical, the result is a mix of many individual tones that sounds like a saw.
You hear it on many turbofan jets, from a narrowbody like the Boeing 737-800 to a widebody on its takeoff roll. It is not a pure type feature, but a good hint at the generation: older jets with a small fan sound more like thunder and roaring on takeoff, modern large-fan jets more like a saw plus a rushing noise. Which engines hang on which type can be found in the guide Identifying engines.
Newer engines are quieter overall. One means to that end is the serrated trailing edges of the nacelle, the chevrons: they mix the exhaust jet more gently with the surrounding air. You find them, for example, on the Boeing 787-9 and on the Boeing 737 MAX 8. If a big twinjet strikes you as noticeably muted on takeoff, that is a sign of the new generation.
The MD-80 thunder: low bypass ratio
Anyone who has heard an MD-80 take off once does not forget the sound. The two rear-mounted Pratt & Whitney JT8D-200 engines produce a deep, rough roar that stands out from a long way off. The reason lies in the bypass ratio: in the -200 series, only about 1.7 times as much air flows around the core engine as through it. A large part of the thrust comes from a fast, hot exhaust jet – and jet noise rises very sharply with exit velocity.
And the -200 series is already the quieter development. The original JT8D, with a bypass ratio of about 1 to 1, powered the Boeing 727-200, the Boeing 737-200 and the DC-9, which were still considerably louder and in many places were only allowed to keep flying with hush-kit retrofits.
In Europe, the MD-80 family has practically disappeared from regular scheduled service as of October 2026. If you want to experience its sound live, you are mainly left with individual operators in the Americas and the occasional ferry or special flight. The type has lasted particularly long in Latin America, for example with Venezuelan airlines such as Laser Airlines. Before any plan, check whether the aircraft are actually still in service.
Its successor in spirit sounds quite different, the Boeing 717-200: it also has rear-mounted engines, but more modern turbofans with a higher bypass ratio – the same silhouette, but a much more civilized soundscape.
| Sound | Typical cause | When you hear it | Points to |
|---|---|---|---|
| High, rising and falling whistle | Pressure relief openings under the wing | on approach, engines near idle | older, non-retrofitted A319/A320/A321 |
| Short, rhythmic bark | Hydraulic Power Transfer Unit | on the ground during start, shutdown, taxiing on one engine | A320 family |
| Buzzing buzzsaw | Supersonic fan blade tips | during the takeoff roll, from the front or diagonally from the side | Turbofans with a large fan |
| Deep, rough roar | fast exhaust jet, low bypass ratio | on takeoff, often echoing for a long time | MD-80, 727, 737-200, DC-9 |
| Steady hum or drone | Propeller blades | in all phases of flight, clear on approach | Turboprops like ATR, Dash 8, C-130, A400M |
| Loud rushing after touchdown | Thrust reversers | right after landing | Jets braking, not type-specific |
Turboprops: hum instead of rush
Turboprops sound fundamentally different from jets. Instead of broadband rushing, you hear a rhythmic hum or drone whose fundamental tone depends on the number of propeller blades and their rotational speed: every blade that sweeps past produces a pressure pulse. More blades at the same speed therefore means a higher fundamental tone. On approach, when the propellers work with adjusted blade pitch, the tone often changes audibly – a hint you can listen for.
ATR 72 and ATR 42: The current versions such as the ATR 72-600 and ATR 42-600 fly with six-blade propellers, while the early ATR 72-200 still had four blades. You hear a peculiarity on the ground: in hotel mode, the right engine runs while a propeller brake holds the propeller fixed. The aircraft thus supplies itself with electricity and air conditioning. So if a rush comes from an ATR whose propeller is standing still, it is no ghost sound – and for you a reason to pay close attention to barriers on the apron.
Dash 8: The Dash 8-400 is faster and more powerfully engined than the ATR. Its PW150A engines turn large six-blade propellers, while the smaller Series 100 to 300 have four blades. How to tell the two families apart visually with confidence is shown in the guide Telling the ATR and Dash 8 apart.
Military turboprops: The classic Lockheed C-130 Hercules with four Allison T56 engines has a steady, penetrating drone that many spotters recognize immediately. The Airbus A400M carries eight blades per propeller, and the two propellers on each wing side turn against each other. Its sound seems deeper and more powerful than the Hercules’. If you hear both types more often, you quickly learn to tell them apart. You experience the A400M especially often at Wunstorf Air Base, the home base of the German A400M fleet – more in the article Plane spotting in Wunstorf.
What did you just hear?
Probably an older A320 family aircraft
The whistle points to an A319, A320 or A321 without vortex generators. Confirm by fuselage length, engines and registration.
A turboprop
Count the propeller blades and look at the tail: a T-tail means ATR or Dash 8, four engines point to C-130 or A400M.
A jet with a low bypass ratio
Rear-mounted engines and a loud roar fit the MD-80 family or another classic. Check whether it might be a quieter 717 or a business jet after all.
The PTU of an A320 family aircraft
One engine is running, the hydraulics are equalizing pressure. You read the exact type from the fuselage length and emergency exits.
Why sound can deceive
As useful as hearing is, it has limits you should know.
- Travel time of sound: Sound takes about three seconds to travel a kilometer. If you follow a sound with your eyes, you are looking behind the aircraft. Scan the sky a bit further ahead in the direction of flight.
- Doppler effect: An approaching aircraft sounds higher than one moving away. Especially with the whistle and the turboprop hum, you hear the tone drop as it passes overhead. That is physics, not a change of type.
- Wind and weather: With the wind, sound carries farther; against the wind, much less reaches you. Temperature layering, humidity and clouds also change how far and how long you hear a takeoff roll.
- Thrust setting and phase of flight: The same aircraft sounds completely different on takeoff at full power than on approach at idle thrust, while taxiing or with the auxiliary power unit running at the gate.
- Surroundings: Halls, terminals and noise barriers reflect sound back or shield it. At large airports, several aircraft also often overlap.
That is why a look at the runway direction in use is worthwhile: if you know which direction landings come from, you can assign approach sounds much better. The guide Flight tracking with ADS-B for spotters helps here, letting you check an auditory guess against real data in seconds.
Do not just hear it, know what is coming
Planetrack tells you via sighting alert when a watched type, airline, registration or special livery is on approach, and shows you wind and runways at the airport. Planetrack is launching soon – join the waitlist and get early access.
How to train your hearing
Recognizing sounds is a matter of practice. With a simple routine, you learn more in a few spotting days than from any video.
1. Listen first, then look
When a sound appears, commit mentally: jet or turboprop, takeoff or landing, old or new. Only then do you look for the aircraft.
2. Compare with the picture
Check your guess against the engines, tail and fuselage length. If your ear was right, consciously remember the sound.
3. Confirm with data
A look at the live map shows you the type and registration. That also tells you whether a whistling A320 is an older build year.
4. Record and compare
Short audio recordings help you lay sounds side by side later. How to go about it is described in the guide on recording engine sound.
For the fourth step, you will find everything on microphones, wind protection and levels in the article Recording engine sound. Good places to practice are spots with a view of takeoffs and landings at once, such as the Munich visitors’ hill or the Zeppelinheim viewing platform at Frankfurt Airport, where you hear lots of traffic of different types in a short time.
What to watch out for
- Pack hearing protection. Right at the runway threshold or next to a turboprop during engine start, it gets very loud. Especially if you stand at the fence for a long time, earplugs or earmuffs protect your most important tool for this topic.
- Do not infer the airline from the sound. The same A320 whistles at one airline and not at the next, depending on retrofit status. The sound says something about the technology, not about the operator.
- Focus on distinctive sounds. Whistling, barking, thundering and propeller hum are easy to tell apart. Subtleties between two modern large-fan jets, on the other hand, are hard even for experienced listeners.
- Never rely on hearing on the apron. A stationary propeller or a quiet auxiliary power unit does not mean that no engine is running. Always follow barriers and instructions.
Are you ready for the listening test at the fence?
- I know where the A320 whistle comes from and why not every A320 whistles.
- I recognize the PTU’s bark on the ground.
- I can tell buzzsaw noise on takeoff from the rough thunder of older jets.
- I hear the difference between turboprop and jet.
- I allow for the travel time of sound and look ahead of the noise.
- I confirm every auditory guess with my eyes or tracking data.
Your sightings in one place
Post sightings with photo, type and registration, plan spots with the spot map and talk with the community about the best sounds at the fence. Planetrack is launching soon – join the waitlist and get early access.
Conclusion
Identifying aircraft by sound is no magic, just applied technology. The older A320 family’s whistle comes from openings under the wing, the bark at the gate from the hydraulics, the buzzsaw on takeoff from supersonic flow at the fan blades and the MD-80’s thunder from its fast exhaust jet. Turboprops give themselves away with their hum, and with a bit of practice you can even tell the Hercules and the A400M apart. Hearing is your early warning system – in the end, identification is done with the eyes.
Quick verdict
Listen for the four distinctive sounds: whistling on approach (older A320 family), barking on the ground (the A320 family’s PTU), thunder on takeoff (jets with a low bypass ratio like the MD-80) and hum (turboprops). Use the sound to raise your camera early, and always confirm the type by its looks or tracking data.
Summary
- Many aircraft sounds have a clear cause: fan, exhaust jet, propeller or the airflow around landing gear, flaps and openings in the airframe.
- The A320 family whistles on approach because of the pressure relief openings under the wings. Since 2014, Airbus has delivered aircraft with vortex generators that largely suppress this tone.
- Older jets with a low bypass ratio such as the MD-80, the 727 or the 737-200 are much louder and rougher than modern large-fan engines.
- You recognize turboprops like the ATR 72, Dash 8 or C-130 by the propeller hum. On the ATR, an engine can run on the ground while the propeller stands still.
Frequently asked questions
Why does the Airbus A320 whistle on approach?
The tone arises at circular openings of the fuel tank pressure relief on the underside of the wing. The air flowing past excites the cavities behind them to vibrate – similar to blowing across the neck of a bottle. Because the engines produce little thrust on approach, the whistle is especially audible then. With small vortex generators in front of the openings, it can be largely eliminated.
Does every A320 whistle?
No. Since February 2014, Airbus has delivered A320 family aircraft with vortex generators, and the parts can also be retrofitted. Lufthansa has also put A320s with vortex generators into service. Whether a particular aircraft still whistles therefore depends on its year of manufacture and retrofit status.
What is the barking you hear from Airbus jets on the ground?
That is the Power Transfer Unit (PTU). It transfers hydraulic power between two hydraulic systems of the A320 family without exchanging fluid. When only one engine is running, for example during engine start, shutdown or taxiing on one engine, it keeps cutting in and out. The jerky spooling up and down sounds like a briefly barking dog.
Why is the MD-80 so loud?
Its Pratt & Whitney JT8D-200 engines have a bypass ratio of only about 1.7 to 1. A large part of the thrust comes from a fast, hot exhaust jet, and jet noise rises sharply with exit velocity. Modern large-fan engines accelerate much more air more slowly and are therefore quieter.
What is the buzzsaw sound at takeoff?
That is so-called buzzsaw noise. It arises when the tips of the fan blades rotate faster than the speed of sound at takeoff power. The shock waves at the blade tips produce a buzzing, sawing sound that is mainly audible in front of and diagonally beside the departing aircraft.
Does an ATR run when the propeller is standing still?
Possibly yes. In so-called hotel mode, the ATR 72’s right engine runs while a propeller brake holds the propeller fixed. That way the aircraft supplies itself with electricity and air conditioning on the ground. A stationary propeller therefore does not mean the aircraft is switched off.
Can I reliably identify aircraft types by sound?
Rarely reliably, often as a first guess. Wind, distance, thrust setting and surrounding buildings change the sound a lot. Very distinctive sounds such as the A320 whistle or the turboprop hum narrow the choices, but you make the actual identification by looking at the fuselage, engines and tail or with tracking data.
Look it up instead of guessing
In the aircraft types database you’ll find a dedicated page for every aircraft type with a profile, identifying features and spotting tips – sorted by manufacturer.
Read more in Identifying aircraft types
- How to tell the A318, A319, A320 and A321 apart
- A320neo or ceo? Engines, Sharklets and other identifying features
- A330 or A340? Spotting engine count, landing gear and variants
- A350 or Boeing 787? Cockpit window mask, wingtips and nose
- A380 or Boeing 747? How to tell the double-deck giants apart
- Airbus or Boeing? How to tell them apart
Related airports & manufacturers
Airports, manufacturers, airline groups and alliances – who is behind them and what you should know as a spotter.
Airbus
European aerospace company and one of the two big manufacturers of commercial aircraft – with aircraft families from the A220 to the A350.
ManufacturerPratt & Whitney
A US engine maker from Connecticut that shaped the short-haul jet age of the 1960s with the JT8D, powered the jumbo with the JT9D and today hangs under the A220, A320neo and E2 with the PW1000G geared turbofan. For spotters, P&W is the reason so many Neos sat on the ground for a while.
ManufacturerATR
The French-Italian manufacturer ATR has built just two aircraft since the 1980s – the ATR 42 and the ATR 72. High wing, T-tail, propellers: once you understand the family, you recognize it everywhere, from Lanzarote to the Greek islands.
Related spotting locations
Specific vantage points with the runway configuration, light times, coordinates and an honest take on whether the trip is worth it.
Zeppelinheim viewing platform at Frankfurt Airport
The classic among Frankfurt’s spotting spots: from the platform at the motorway bridge near Zeppelinheim, most landings in a west wind glide in onto the south runway – free, public and a quick S-Bahn ride from Frankfurt Hauptbahnhof.
Spotting hillMunich Airport visitors’ hill (Besucherhügel)
The best-known vantage point at Lufthansa’s Munich hub: from the visitors’ hill in the Besucherpark you look out over the airport grounds from above – with its own S-Bahn stop right next door.
You might also like
How to identify jet engines: CFM56, LEAP, V2500, PW1000G, Trent, GE90 and GEnx
Which engine is hanging under that wing? With nacelle shape, fan size, chevrons and knowing which type carries which engines, you can identify the CFM56, LEAP, V2500, PW1000G, Trent, GE90 and GEnx with confidence.
Identifying aircraft typesATR or Dash 8? How to tell turboprops apart with confidence
High wing, T-tail, two propellers – the ATR and Dash 8 look easy to mix up. How to tell them apart right away anyway, how to separate the ATR 42 and 72 or the Dash 8 series, and how to place Saab, Fokker, Dornier and others.
Video & contentRecording engine sound: microphones, wind protection and levels
A takeoff is first of all an acoustic event. Here is how to choose a microphone and recorder, protect the recording from wind, set levels correctly and get the delayed sound back in sync with the picture.



